BOOK REVIEWS    Sue Parrill, Editor


Persuasion-Spotting

Jane Austen in Scarsdale: Or Love, Death, and the SATs

By Paula Marantz Cohen.
St. Martin’s Press, 2006. 275 pages. Hardcover. $23.95.

Reviewed by Janine Barchas.

While this is not Cohen’s first adaptation of Austen (she previously reset Pride and Prejudice in a Florida retirement community), it is surely her best yet. The heroine of this smart modernization of Persuasion is Anne Erlich, a 34-year-old guidance counselor at Fenimore High School. At the age of 21, Anne followed the advice of her kvetchy grandmother Winnie and ended her relationship with Ben Cutler—then a penniless graduate from Queens College working at a travel agency. Now, 13 years later (Cohen valiantly staves off spinsterhood for the modern woman by half a decade when she adds five to Austen’s eight!), Ben has acquired the status of a “travel mogul” with an acclaimed series of books called Cutler’s Guides to Cultures. They meet again when Ben returns from Europe to enroll his nephew in Fenimore High. Ben’s financial rise has coincided with the Erlichs’ decline. Whereas Anne’s grandmother Winnie was once regarded as “Westchester royalty,” her spendthrift father, the widowed Elihu Erlich, has burned through the family fortune with shopping sprees on Burberry wear, Ralph Lauren décor, and club memberships. As a result, the Erlichs must sell their Scarsdale homestead. On cue, Ben Cutler offers to buy the 3 million dollar property. In the transactions surrounding the sale, Winnie, now 87 and tamed by ill health and episodes of General Hospital, strikes up a bizarre friendship with the Cutlers that places Anne in awkward proximity to Ben and his new fiancée, the stylish Kirsten Knudsen from Copenhagen.

The wit of this refashioning of Persuasion sparkles from the brilliant (because a tad gaudy) equivalents found for Austen’s original situations. For example, whereas Austen’s novel opens with Walter Elliot’s obsessive reading of the Baronetage, Cohen begins hers with a fiery speech from an “Ivy Packager,” a college consultant eager to exploit parental anxiety about college admissions. Thus the British social hierarchy of the peerage is replaced with the contemporary American obsession with school rankings, GPAs, and standardized test scores. Four years at Yale, Harvard, or (in a pinch) Stanford supplant the old pedigrees of birth and marriage. The substitution is as much a gloss of Austen’s original intention as it is an apt contemporary social critique. Similarly, the narcissistic Sir Walter Elliot is played by the vain Elihu Erlich—“a regular at Elizabeth Arden.” The artful Mrs. Clay appears as “preening ingrate” Carlotta Dupre, the professional sponger who takes advantage when she sublets Anne’s apartment. Carlotta menacingly shows up on Elihu’s arm at parties, but eventually undergoes a surprisingly sympathetic reveal as porn star Candy Delight.

The cleverest equivalencies concern Austen’s Captain Benwick, on whom Austen bestowed a tragic past along with a predilection for Romantic poetry. Cohen reinvents him as Peter Jacobson, a contemporary poet and winner of the unknown Pitzer Prize (named, we are told, in the hopes of being confused with the Pulitzer). Peter, like Benwick before him, lost his girlfriend to illness—in this case “a rare blood disease”—and the wake of his bereavement stirs Anne’s sympathies. After Peter holds a poetry workshop at Fenimore High School, Anne agrees to go out on a date with him to an exhibit of mortuary sculpture—a rather witty gloss of Benwick’s selfindulgent reading. Eventually Peter helps nurse Anne’s cousin Rachel, an out-of-work actress and the stand-in for Louisa Musgrove, during a protracted recovery from illness. While I don’t wish to spoil the fun of Persuasion-spotting for others by detailing how Cohen manages to rework Louisa’s fall at Lyme Regis into her adaptation, allow me to hint that Robert Frost’s “Mending Wall” ingeniously figures in the scene.

The high-school setting of Cohen’s novel invites comparison with Clueless, Amy Heckerling’s 1995 film adaptation of Emma. Like Clueless, Cohen’s redesign of Austen brings an old novel up-to-date. Unlike Clueless, which initially hid its debt to Emma from teenage fans, Cohen includes a number of selfconscious references to Austen that wink at her target audience. At one point, Winnie chides Anne: “Life isn’t a Jane Austen novel. It’s one thing to be longsuffering in a story, where the author can make it worth your while, but in real life, who’s going to make sure it ends happily? Just look at what happened with poor Jane Austen. She worked things out for that long-suffering ninny, Anne Elliot, in her last book, but who worked things out for her?” In the tradition of parallel translation, Cohen ensures that her reader remembers the original. Cohen realizes that the better you know Austen, the more you will enjoy her visit to Scarsdale.


Janine Barchas, who conveniently claims not to remember her SAT scores, went to Stanford, followed by graduate school at the University of Chicago. She is the author of Graphic Design, Print Culture and the Eighteenth-Century Novel (Cambridge University Press, 2003).

JASNA News v.23, no.
3 , Winter 2007, p. 18

See more book reviews

Return to Home Page